Thursday, July 21, 2016

DOJ Charges HSBC Traders with FX Front Running

In the DOJ's first charges against individuals in the FX market investigations of the last three years, HSBC's head of FX trading and a former colleague were charged with using inside information from a large forthcoming client trade to make an $8 million profit for the bank (and we assume thereby increasing their bonuses).

While many charges have been made and settled with the banks, here individuals are being charged, perhaps in response to claims that just as in the financial crisis, fines are levied but no individuals are held responsible. Earlier this week the Fed barred a UBS trader from the currency markets for life, due to participation in the FX currency benchmark rigging scandal. There may be a few more charges to come both in the US and Europe, for regulators to show that more than financial penalties against the banks will be levied in this and any future financial scandals.

Friday, May 20, 2016

State Street Bank to Settle FX Overcharges Lawsuit and Investigations

The Wall Street Journal reported that State Street is finalizing a settlement with the DOJ, SEC and Labor Department (due to ERISA clients), as well as lawsuits filed on behalf of investors including CalPERS and CalSTRS pension funds. The dollar amount is expected to exceed $500 million (BNY Mellon settled a similar suit last year for over $700 million). The suit involves standing instruction trades - custody FX trades executed automatically based upon an agreement with the customer. The lawsuit charges that while the bank promised to execute these trades at market prices, there were undisclosed markups in the rates provided to clients.

These charges were different and preceded the FX benchmark manipulation charges and lawsuits, to which State Street was not a part. Here the State Street charges were that the bank contractually agreed to provide market prices but instead provided clients with worse rates. The charges only relate to standing instruction trades, typically used for "smaller" FX trades by the custody clients of banks.

Thursday, May 5, 2016

Banks Settle Interest Rate Manipulation Lawsuit

Seven banks have settled a class action lawsuit brought in the US regarding the ISDAfix. The ISDAfix is a benchmark rate used in daily pricing of trillions of US dollars in derivatives, including interest rate swaps, futures and exchange traded options. The seven are JP Morgan, RBS, Deutsche, Credit Suisse, Barclay's, Citi and BOA.

The lead law firm, Scott + Scott, is the same as in the FX benchmark manipulation class action suit. The charges are similar to the FX suit and to the LIBOR charges as well. The charges included placing numerous orders at the close ("banging the close"), collusion leading to to submission of identical orders and placing off-market rates. Eight other banks remain in the suit. If this follows the trajectory of the FX suit, banks that settle later will tend to pay larger settlements.

Monday, May 2, 2016

What Does the New Treasury Currency Watch List Mean?

A recent US law requires the Treasury to publish an annual list of countries that may be manipulating their currency. This first list does not name any country as a manipulator but mentions China, Germany, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan as countries that exceed one or two of the three criteria for being named as such -

1) an annual bilateral trade surplus with the US exceeding $20 billion
2) a current account surplus exceeding 3% of GDP
3) FX market interventions exceeding 2% of GDP in a given year

Prior Treasury reports on currency manipulation were based upon fuzzy guidelines and the intention of the new rules is to hold Treasury to using specific financial/economic data with the intent of more frequent designations of manipulation (the most recent Treasury designation was of China in 1994).

Will these new rules lead to more currency manipulation designations? Our answer is probably not. While the first two metrics are fairly clear the third is not always. FX market interventions are not necessarily publicized (even if highly suspected). As well, in a time of quantitative easing (QE), it is far from clear if selling one's currency and buying others is the only way to intervene in currency markets. It is often suspected that at least part of the reasons for QE, even if unmentioned publicly, is to weaken the local currency. As such, rules focusing on direct interventions may miss, or cause the increased use of, indirect currency interventions.

Friday, April 29, 2016

EU Parliament Passes New Benchmark Rules

This week the EU Parliament addressed the benchmark rate rigging scandals that have plagued financial markets for the past several years, including LIBOR, FX, gold and oil. The goal is to “clean up the benchmark-setting process, improve transparency and prevent conflicts of interest.”

While not yet implemented, new rules will affect benchmarks while breaking them into three categories based upon the size of the instruments and/or contracts influenced (over Euro 500 billion, over 50 billion or below 50 billion). Administrators of benchmark rates will need to create structures to prevent conflicts of interest, will be subject to controls, will have to be authorized or registered, and will need to publish their methodology and procedures for calculating each benchmark. As well, quality standards will have to be put in place for the data used to set benchmarks.

Wednesday, March 16, 2016

UK Fraud Agency Drops FX Rigging Investigation

The Serious Fraud Office, a British government fraud agency that investigates and prosecutes complex frauds, has announced that it is dropping the FX fix manipulation investigation. While several government agencies around the world investigated and settled with banks for over $10 billion in fines (with many banks pleading guilty to felony charges), the SFO announced that it is dropping its investigation (while continuing to liase with the US Justice dept in its investigation of FX fix manipulation). It said that there was insufficient evidence to realistically gain a conviction.

The lion share of FX trading occurs in the UK. We will have to wait and see the effect of this matter on the law suits that reportedly are being considered for filing in the UK, as well as on further regulatory investigations in the US and elsewhere.

Tuesday, December 8, 2015

ECB to Inhibit Trading Utilizing Daily EUR Reference Rates

The ECB publishes reference rates on 30 currencies at 2:30 PM each day, based upon spot rates at 2:15 PM. The ECB wants these to be used for reference or informational purposes only, not for trading. The ECB has not said whether or not it suspects rigging of these daily rates, as existed in the WM Reuters daily fixings. As of July 1, 2016 these rates will not be published until 4:00 PM, thus seemingly reducing their usefulness as a basis for trading or for that matter, for rate-rigging by any parties interested in such behavior. The ECB said this change is a reaction to recommendations by regulators reforming global FX benchmarks.

It has been our experience that these rates are used for trading, particularly by asset managers, although not to the degree to which WM Reuters rates are used. Any such traders after July 1 will have to either utilize other means to trade or wait much longer between when positions are provided and trade rates are known. This time is at a minimum an operational delay/complication, or worse, an additional operational risk.