Regulatory Investigations of the FX Markets are Progressing

Bloomberg reports that the U.K.'s FCA is trying to speed up settlement talks with the banks by keeping the settlement narrowly focused.  The FCA is hoping for a settlement before year end, much earlier than previous reports.  The SFO in the UK has recently begun a criminal investigation and the director said that charges could come next year.  It is reported that the DOJ's investigation could bring charges and impose fines as early as this year.

The WSJ also reports that a number of banks are negotiating with the UK's FCA that any settlement will be announced at the same time for all of the banks.  This is an attempt to avoid the LIBOR scenario where each bank settlement was announced separately, bringing considerable bad publicity to each.  Perhaps a cross bank settlement would spread such publicity around and also draw attention to the misconduct being more of a market-wide problem rather than any bank being a bad apple.

New York's bank regulator, the Department of Financial Services, is negotiating with Barclay's and Deutsche Bank to install monitors at the two banks to investigate whether trades manipulated FX currency benchmark rates.  This was reported by the Wall Street Journal , but both banks declined comment.

All in all it sounds as if the regulators are attempting to fast track the investigations.  Earlier this year the FCA had mentioned 2015 as a goal and BAFIN in Germany had mentioned completion in 2018, hopefully. Speed will be helpful for all involved - the banks, regulators, and oh yes, market participants.  The discussions on changes to benchmarks is ongoing publicly, but no solution is perfect - longer windows of trading which seems to be a favorite, mitigates but does not eliminate the possibility of misconduct and a benchmark that is more of an average rate for the day is not what all market participants are looking for.

FSB Proposes FX Benchmark Changes; UK Opens Criminal FX Benchmark Investigation

The Financial Stability Board (coordinates national regulators and international standard setting bodies)  published suggested changes to FX benchmark calculations in the following areas:

• The calculation methodology of the WM/Reuters (WMR) benchmark rates;
• The publication of reference rates by central banks;
• Market infrastructure in relation to the execution of fix trades;
• The behaviour of market participants around the time of the major FX benchmarks (primarily the WMR 4pm London fix);
• Recommendations from a forthcoming IOSCO review of the WMR fixes.

These are open to comments and should entail great diversity as there is much disagreement on how to reduce the possibility of rate rigging in FX markets.

In the UK, the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) has opened a criminal investigation into possible fraud occurring in benchmark rate setting.  The US DOJ has been looking into criminal angles for quite some time,and last week we reported their offer of immunity to junior FX traders in exchange for information. The SFO has an ongoing investigation into LIBOR rigging as well.